When setting up a virtual server, an important decision is choosing the best server OS for your tasks. The operating system will largely determine the server's overall functionality and affect its performance and security.
In this article, we'll examine several available options and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each so you can make an informed choice.
Let's define the list of factors that the hosting operating system influences:
An operating system is software that manages hardware and provides an interface for interacting with it. Like any software, the operating system consumes part of the computing resources. For example, Windows Server will consume more than Ubuntu Server due to factors like the graphical interface.
Before installing a particular operating system, determine whether you need the services and functionality it provides. A graphical interface won't affect web server functionality at all. Are you willing to spend additional resources on more comfortable administration?
In general, most software will be available to both Linux and Windows users. Developers are interested in having versions for different operating systems. Even some Microsoft applications, which theoretically should be interested in promoting their operating systems, run on Linux—for example, MS SQL databases. But, of course, not all Microsoft software can be run on Linux.
For Windows, there's a special software layer that allows running Linux applications—WSL. If a Windows port of the application doesn't exist, WSL will help run it.
Both Windows and Linux allow users to perform most work tasks. Compatibility affects administration convenience and performance. For example, PHP is available on both operating systems, but on Linux it runs faster. And running some applications will require additional effort.
Cases where technology is only available on one operating system are rather exceptions. For example, if a company needs a terminal server or Active Directory, they'll have to use Windows Server.
Almost all Linux distributions are distributed free of charge, while you'll have to pay for Windows Server and additional components.
What's more secure: Windows or Linux? This is quite a debatable question. In general, each operating system has a sufficient number of information security tools available.
System security primarily depends on the user. You can catch a virus on both Windows and Linux. But the probability of catching a virus on Windows is higher, simply because most viruses target Windows systems.
Windows is one of the most popular operating systems. In 2008, Microsoft released a special version for virtual servers—Windows Server.
Windows Server offers high performance, a rich set of features, and broad compatibility with other software and services. However, it can be more expensive in terms of licensing. Windows Server has many different versions, each with its own features and areas of application.
Depending on the Windows Server version, additional functionality may be available to the user. For example, cloud infrastructure support, improved resource management and security, and tools for easier server management and monitoring. Depending on the specific business needs and constraints, one of the Windows Server versions may be better suited for use on a virtual server.
Ease of use. Windows Server has a familiar and understandable interface that's easy to learn.
Compatibility. Windows operating systems are very widespread, and many applications have versions specifically for them. For working with applications that don't have a special Windows version, WSL exists.
Support. Windows Server has extended support from Microsoft, which means the server will receive updates for a long time.
Integration with other Microsoft products. Windows Server easily integrates with other Microsoft products, such as Active Directory, Exchange, and SharePoint.
Complexity of hosting websites. When working on Windows, as with any other operating system, you can host websites, but it will be more complex.
Licensing cost. Many solutions that are free to use on Linux require paid licenses on Windows Server.
Security vulnerabilities. Many viruses target Windows operating systems specifically, which increases the risk of server infection.
Hardware requirements. Windows Server is quite demanding on hardware, and versions newer than Windows Server 2008 don't support 32-bit architecture.
Virtual servers are mainly used by companies and enterprises, not private individuals. For them, the question of benefit stands above the convenience of a familiar interface. Therefore, using Windows Server as a server operating system is usually the exception rather than the rule. For example, Windows Server is used to implement remote desktops and terminal servers.
The Linux kernel is the heart of the Linux family operating system. It's a set of software that provides basic functions: memory management, filesystem operations, and communication with hardware. The Linux kernel provides the connection between software and computer hardware, allowing programs to interact with computer resources. It also provides mechanisms for multitasking, allowing multiple programs to run simultaneously and ensuring their security.
Linux operating systems are various Linux distributions that have their own features and toolsets. Each distribution is suitable as an operating system for a server, but they are usually used for different purposes: Ubuntu is used as a desktop OS, Debian as a base for other distributions, Kali Linux for network security, and distributions like Rocky Linux or AlmaLinux for server tasks. Next, we'll look at some of these systems and talk about what tasks they should be used for as operating systems for VPS/VDS.
Advantages of Linux systems:
Disadvantages:
Debian is an operating system based on the Linux kernel and freely distributed under the GNU GPL license. Debian is one of the most stable and reliable Linux distributions and supports a large number of processor architectures, including x86, x86-64, ARM, MIPS, and PowerPC.
Debian has a package manager mechanism that allows easy installation and updating of software, as well as creating backups and restoring the system. Debian also has a configuration management system that allows easy system setup and administration.
For server tasks, Debian provides stability and long-term support, which are necessary for reliable long-term server operation. It also has many tools for server monitoring and management, as well as an extensive support community for problem-solving.
Ubuntu Server is one of the Debian-based distributions used in server environments. It's the familiar Ubuntu OS to many, but without a graphical interface. Interaction is carried out through the terminal.
Ubuntu Server offers a high degree of stability and reliability, as well as extended system management and configuration capabilities. It also has an apt package manager, which makes it easy to install and update software.
Ubuntu Server is used for deploying web servers, databases, network equipment, cloud services, and much more. It also supports virtualization and is used as a guest OS in virtualization environments such as VMware and VirtualBox.
Kali Linux is a Linux distribution specializing in information security and penetration testing tools. It's based on Debian and has over 600 tools for conducting security tests. If you plan to work in information security, then Kali Linux is ideal for this task.
In addition, Kali Linux is also used for information security training and practicing skills in this area. However, it should be kept in mind that some tools in Kali Linux may be illegal or unethical in some countries and jurisdictions, and their use may violate laws and regulations. Therefore, before using Kali Linux, you need to ensure that you're acting in accordance with applicable law.
Note: CentOS, which was previously popular for server tasks, ended its traditional support model in 2021. CentOS Stream became a rolling-release distribution that serves as an upstream development platform for Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL), making it less suitable for production servers that require stability.
As a result, the community created two enterprise-grade alternatives that continue the legacy of CentOS: Rocky Linux and AlmaLinux.
Rocky Linux and AlmaLinux are free, open-source distributions created as direct replacements for CentOS. Both are built from RHEL sources and offer long-term support and stability, maintaining binary compatibility with RHEL.
One of the main advantages of these distributions is that they provide proven and reliable software and security and stability updates. They also have the dnf package manager (evolution of yum), which allows easy installation and updating of software.
As server operating systems, Rocky Linux and AlmaLinux are used for deploying web servers, databases, network equipment, and various services. They're also suitable for use in virtualized environments such as VMware and VirtualBox.
If you don't plan to use your server for high-load tasks, then Ubuntu or another desktop Debian distribution with a friendly interface will suit you, in which you'll be comfortable working.
If we're talking about using a server in commerce with high load, then choose Rocky Linux or AlmaLinux. These operating systems are oriented toward use in such conditions.
If you want to work in information security, then choose Kali Linux.
In this article, we examined the main operating system options for a virtual server. Each has its own advantages, disadvantages, and areas of application. Still, it's important to remember that the listed operating systems, in most cases, provide a decent level of performance and operability.